Louise Murphy
With hundreds of books and bloggers writing about so many different things at the same time it's almost a source of comfort to simply surround yourself with the books you have and simply admit that hey, not reading all highly recommended books isn't that big a problem. But there are books that get your attention amidst everything that is out there. And this is one of them.I first became aware of the book during the 12th Edition of Bookworms Carnival where Nymeth compiled posts relating to fairy tales. There was a discussion about the author's take on Hansel and Gretel at Natasha's blog and most of the readers chipped in their thoughts, particularly with respect to a negative review culled from Amazon. It was a healthy exchange of ideas. Consequently when my name was drawn from the hat to pick any book from all the Carnival posts I chose this one.
And now my mind is blank. I'm trying to remember as I read this last month. It's not that I can't, it's just difficult and not just a tad painful to recall the entire story given the nature of the subject matter.
There's a stepmother indeed. And two kids sent scurrying to the forest. They found an old, ostracized woman living alone in the woods. But this is not a fairy tale. This is the story of two Jews, the two children, trying to escape the horrors of Hitler's edict that the world be purged of people other than the Aryan race.
It starts with a chase. A family trying to escape a handful of Hitler's men in the outskirts of Bialowieza Forest. The woman, stepmother to the two children, reasoned with her husband to let the children off to the forest to allow them a chance to escape. Christening the children as Hansel and Gretel, the two were told never to mention their real names, never bring up their past, never to let on that they were in fact Jews. With that, the spouses tried to use the remainder of the petrol to drive off as far away as possible from the children's drop off point and as the petrol ran out, a footrace with the Nazis became inevitable.
This is the story of that two children we only know as Hansel and Gretel. Of how they chanced upon Magda, the witch, and of that small hamlet where the people are trying as much as they can to survive the war. A hamlet almost forgotten that the visit of a high-ranking SS officer caused fear to spread in their hearts like wildfire. This is the story of the husband and wife after leaving the children and their search for the two afterward. This is the story of people wanting a lot of things: escape, revenge, reason, survival. This is a story of the Holocaust recreated in the essence of a grim (and Grimm) fairy tale. It is fiction and yet it is real, it feels real and it must have been real in other guises way back then.
It is a powerful, moving story but it is not for everyone. I say that because of its unforgiving take on the war, a subject painful enough as it is and reading it is distressing. I rarely bracket readers into categories but this is definitely for mature ones. I say that without referring to any age of course given that some people do have childish thoughts even if they are past 30 and some young ones can be a little too precocious and well-above the maturity level of the former. That being said, some scenes are disturbing and graphic but I find them apt for the type of story being told.
While elements of the fairy tale were integrated seamlessly by Murphy, she also managed to negate the stereotypes against witches and stepmothers you can't help but be thankful of them in this tale; their presence in the story felt like little victories amidst the pain and suffering of those times.
Books about the Holocaust or any other instances of war are never easy reads, be they factual or imagined. They force us to take stock at the depths of depravity fellow human beings fall under, remind us how easy it is to be weak against a will deemed far stronger than ours. They also show the tenacity, the perseverance, the refusal to give up of those who survived them. They teach us to hope in spite of everything. In a sense it almost always bittersweet to go through them given the emotional roller coaster one feels through the stories. But go through them you must, at the very least that's how I feel. In doing so you honor the memory of those who suffered. It also gives you the opportunity to treat others fairly, judiciously; because little depravities, little acts of villainy matter once you've glimpsed the darker side of other people through the eyes of those who suffered the most.
Read this. You must.
Other interesting points of view:
Book Addiction
Maw Books Blog
Random Wonder
Sonderbooks
What Cheesy Reads
What We're Reading Now
You've Gotta Read This
-----
My thanks again to Nymeth for my copy of the book.
*A song by Tears for Fears that I can't get out of my head for one reason or another while typing this up.







