The MagiciansLev Grossman
The premise is simple if not familiar to at least half the world's book-loving population: there's a magical school out there teaching magical basics, theories and applications to those admitted inside its gates. They only select the best crop of intellectually gifted individuals out there. Here comes Quentin Coldwater, one of the nerdiest of nerds set to graduate high school and preparing for his interview with an Ivy League school. Instead, he discovers the dead body of his would-be interviewer and eventually found himself taking the exams for Brakebills, that magical college located in New York.
To make the story more familiar, Quentin loves a series of magical books set in Fillory, an enchanted place one visits through uh, let's start with grandfather clock for now. He doesn't want to admit that he hadn't outgrown the need to escape to those pages and pages of magical places and adventures where siblings get to visit and rule Fillory, albeit for a brief time. You see, Quentin is one unhappy kid.
I should be happy, Quentin thought. I'm young and alive and healthy. I have good friends. I have two reasonably intact parents - viz., Dad, an editor of medical textbooks, and mom, a commercial illustrator with ambitions, thwarted, of being a painter. I am a solid member of the middle-middle class. My GPA is a number higher than most people even realize it is possible for a GPA to be.
But walking along Fifth Avenue in Brooklyn, in his black overcoat and his gray interview suit, Quentin knew he wasn't happy. Why not? He had painstakingly assembled all the ingreadients of happiness. He had performed all the necessary rituals, spoken the words, lit the candles, made the sacrifices. But happiness, like a disobedient spirit, refuses to come. He couldn't think of what else to do.
Where do I start? I love stories. I love reading a good, story no matter what genre. Either the plot gets me and I applaud the author for conjuring twists and turns that make your insides go awry without having to use anything except your brains, emotions, what-have-yous, or the characters feel like I've known them all my life and I have this hankering for meeting them or reviling them for the rest of my life. When both my love for the plot and the characters fuse into one then it's like finding the perfect song to match my moodiest of moods.
This is more of reviling-the-characters type. Hahaha! If you haven't read the book I suggest you stop reading this post like right now.
To say that it's a combination merely of the Harry Potter series and the Chronicles of Narnia set in New York is missing the point altogether. It is not, even though the author heavily borrows from the ideas of those books. The book anchors on that though. The easy familiarity not to mention reference to Harry Potter is unmistakable and yet the author takes a shot at Hogwarts by making a slight at wand use. It's just one sentence, easily forgotten, but it's there alright.
If you don't take into account the magical element of the first part of the story it's simple enough; college life. How the nerdiest, most intelligent crop of young men and women spend their time inside the gates of an exclusive school; like not knowing what to major, the tentativeness of making new friends, the alienation with one's parents after a term from school, the awkwardness in seeing old friends and realizing you don't share anything in common with them anymore, and since they're all bright of course the need to be on top.
Since the entire four or so years in college are compressed into a handful of chapters of course you get a short version. Except that there was a major supernatural death swept under the rug in the process.
And then, for a bunch of graduates from magical school they discovered that the magical world of Fillory is indeed real. Oh goodness, really? Like gee, I've been waiting for that revelation from the time Quentin found an unpublished installment during the first few pages of the book! You'd think that a school which prides itself for having the best of the bunch, whose graduates would get a demon embedded in their back as protection, would somehow mention to their students that indeed there are lots of magical worlds out there, Fillory included, so be careful. But no. So off they went to Fillory, heigh-ho!
One can find lots of topics for discussion after reading this book. Let's see; there's responsibility or lack of it not just from the part of the Brakebills students but from the teachers as well depending on how you'd view the journey into Fillory, striving to be the best of what you can do with the magic that you know, the meaning of sacrifice, adventure as a form of escape or metaphor, and more but I'd probably save that on those who might like to discuss the book with me. Or not.
Thing is, I cannot find a single character to like but know this: I intensely disliked Quentin, the lead. You know that feeling when you start reading a book and on the very first few pages you get that part where the character is being introduced (see the quoted parts above) and you so much want to like him or find a certain similarity (though not exactly the part being the nerdiest of nerds) and hope for the best only to come up short somewhere before the middle part of the book? That's the sad feeling of disappointment. I wanted to like Quentin, really. He was this selfish, intelligent, bored guy going through college with his head in the clouds. And more than three hundred pages later he barely even changed. I mean, what do you expect from a bright guy who'd rather get high than be responsible? One guy who believes he's deserves happiness? One guy who's now an adept at magic and yet still bored to the very core?
Gee, I mean even Spiderman learned his lesson after a major heartbreak, that whether you've seen the movie, read the comics or learned of the story offhand. Oh sorry, I likened Quentin to Spiderman (Peter Parker) during the first parts of the book, particularly when he was accepted to Brakebills and started doing a few magical card tricks for show. But for a bright guy like Quentin, I feel that everything that has happened to him barely scratched his emotional surface. Oh wait, he doesn't have an emotional surface. He's just a guy with a certain sense of entitlement and nothing more. Such a waste of gray cells, really. That while he felt devastated with the consequences of the trip to Fillory, I cannot escape that last scene and his last choice. Then again, that's the problem with the brightest, the nerdiest of nerds everywhere: I think they think they are gods. Ah, hasty generalization. Hahaha!
But the writing, goodness. Flawless writing, I cannot complain. Well, I can. The book dragged somewhere before graduation when I was eagerly anticipating the Fillory revelation. By then I was getting fed up with Quentin anyway. Still I kept on reading. I mean, I've always enjoyed reading Grossman on Time. There are more than a handful of quotable quotes, memorable scenes and all that if I set my mind to it but right now I can't bear to open the book yet as I'd rather not encounter Quentin again. One moment of pure brilliance for me was when the students transformed into a flock of geese. I loved that part. It was probably the only time I enjoyed Quentin's thoughts excepting the first few chapters into the college.
And yet, the sad thing about Quentin and his school mates altogether is that they're very much real. The nerdy, bright, bored, petty, irresponsible guys and girls who think the world is their playground. Maybe that's why I disliked them a lot. Good job, Grossman!
Other interesting points of view:
A Dribble of InkAsking the Wrong QuestionsBeyond BooksBirdbrain(ed) Book BlogBookshelves of DoomFyrefly's Book BlogJenny's BooksMadgirlNormality RestoredOF Blog of the FallenPajiba - Scathing Reviews for Bitchy PeopleReading the LeavesShe is Too Fond of BooksS. Krishna's BooksStephanie's Written WordThe Celebrity CafeThe Mad Hatter's Bookshelf and Book ReviewsThe WertzoneWordsmithonia